Why This Market Saying Still Gets Attention

Every spring, some version of the same question comes back.

“Should we take some money off the table?”

Sometimes it is tied to “Sell in May.” Sometimes it is election headlines. Sometimes it is interest rates, the Fed, inflation, banks, wars, oil, AI stocks, China, Washington, or whatever happens to be loudest that week.The headline changes. The feeling underneath it usually does not. Most investors are not really asking about May. They are asking, “Are we okay if markets fall?” Or, more quietly, “Did we get too comfortable?” That is a fair question.After a good market run, people start to feel wealthier. They spend a little more freely. They delay rebalancing. They tell themselves the concentrated position is fine because it has worked so far. Then a few ugly market days show up and suddenly the same portfolio that felt brilliant in March feels reckless in June.

I have seen that movie more than once. The calendar did not create the risk. The risk was already there. The calendar just gave people a reason to look at it.

The Problem With Seasonal Advice

Seasonal market advice treats investors like they all have the same life.They do not. A retired couple living off portfolio withdrawals is not in the same position as a 52-year-old business owner still building wealth. A widow with taxable accounts, inherited assets, and a large home in Sarasota is not dealing with the same decisions as an executive with restricted stock and deferred compensation.Same market. Very different consequences. That is why  “Should I sell?”  is usually too blunt a question. It skips over the real work.

A better set of questions sounds more like this:

• What money do we need in the next 12 to 24 months?
• What assets would we actually sell if we needed cash?
• What tax cost would that create?
• Are we sitting on too much of one stock, one sector, one fund family, or one story?
• Would selling make the plan better, or just make us feel better for a few weeks?

That last one is worth sitting with. Sometimes a portfolio change is needed. Sometimes the investor just needs to see the plan again. Both happen.

Liquidity Is Boring Until It Saves You

Liquidity does not get people excited at dinner parties. Nobody brags about having a thoughtful cash reserve. They brag about the stock they bought, the building they sold, the private deal they got into, or the account that doubled.But when markets are down and a client needs cash, liquidity suddenly becomes the most interesting part of the plan.

Retirees know this in a very practical way. Summer spending can creep up. Travel. Grandchildren. Home repairs. Weddings. Boats. Second homes. A larger-than-expected tax payment. Maybe a family member needs help. Maybe the air conditioner dies in August in Florida, which is not a theoretical risk. It is practically a recurring line item. If all the cash is tied up, the portfolio has to fund life whether markets are cooperating or not.

That is not ideal.Good liquidity planning gives a family room to breathe. It can help prevent the long-term portfolio from becoming the checking account. That is a big distinction.For affluent retirees, I usually want to know where the next year or two of known spending is coming from before we start debating market seasonality. Not because cash is magic. It is not. But because forced selling is where many avoidable mistakes begin.

Taxes Change the Answer

A lot of market commentary ignores taxes because taxes make the conversation messier. Real wealth planning is messy. For taxable investors, selling is not just an investment decision. It may trigger capital gains. It may affect estimated taxes. It may influence Medicare premium brackets. It may change the timing of charitable gifts, Roth conversions, or future estate planning moves. I have seen investors make a “defensive” move that looked reasonable before taxes and far less attractive after taxes.

That does not mean you should never sell appreciated assets. That is another mistake. I have also seen people hold oversized positions for years because they did not want to pay the tax. Eventually the tax tail started wagging the whole dog.

Low-basis stock can be a blessing. It can also become a cage. The question is not, “How do we avoid tax at all costs?” The better question is, “What is the tax-aware way to reduce risk without doing something sloppy?” Sometimes that means trimming gradually. Sometimes it means pairing gains with losses. Sometimes it means gifting appreciated securities. Sometimes it means using cash flow, charitable planning, or estate strategy to work around the position over time. Not always. But often enough that it deserves a real review.

Rebalancing Is Not a Prediction

Rebalancing gets misunderstood. It is not a fancy way of saying, “We think the market is about to fall.”

It is simply saying, “The portfolio no longer looks like what we agreed it should look like.” That can happen after a strong run. It can happen after a certain sector takes over the account. It can happen when one stock becomes too large because nobody wanted to touch it while it was working. This is especially common with business owners and executives. They are used to concentration. Concentration built the business. Concentration built the wealth. So diversification can feel emotionally backward, almost like admitting the original success was fragile. It is not.

Diversification is not an insult to success. It is how you stop one success from controlling the rest of your life. That is a line many affluent families eventually have to cross. Rebalancing does not have to be dramatic. In many cases, the best version is quiet and tax-aware. Trim a little. Refill liquidity. Reduce one overweight. Bring the risk back inside the guardrails. No grand market forecast required.

Retirement Makes Volatility Feel Different

When you are still working, volatility is annoying. When you are retired, it can feel personal. A 15% market decline is one thing when paychecks are still coming in. It feels different when the portfolio is helping pay for groceries, travel, property taxes, insurance, healthcare, and gifts to children or grandchildren. The math may still work. But the emotion changes. That is why retirement portfolios need more than a return target. They need a withdrawal strategy. They need a tax strategy. They need a liquidity structure. They need some understanding of which assets are funding today, which assets are funding later, and which assets are really there for legacy.

Without that structure, every market decline feels like it is attacking the whole plan. With structure, a retiree can usually see things more clearly.

• This bucket funds near-term income.
• This part is for later retirement.
• This part is growth.
• This part is legacy.

Markets can still be uncomfortable. But discomfort is easier to handle when the money has a job.

Practical Planning Considerations

1. Look at the Next 12 to 24 Months First

Before debating whether to reduce market exposure, list the known cash needs.Retirement withdrawals. Estimated taxes. Travel. Home repairs. Insurance. Charitable gifts. Tuition. Family help. Capital calls. Large purchases. Anything that is reasonably foreseeable.Then ask a simple question: where will that money come from?If the answer is “we will sell something when needed,” tighten that up. That is not a plan. That is a hope with a brokerage login.

2. Review What Has Quietly Become Too Large

Risk often sneaks in through success. The stock that did well becomes too big. The sector that carried the portfolio keeps getting larger. The private investment allocation expands. The business remains the biggest asset by far, even after the family thinks they are diversified.Look at the actual exposure, not just the account titles.Many investors are more concentrated than they think.

3. Check the Tax Cost Before You Trade

Before selling appreciated positions, review the unrealized gains, tax bracket impact, state tax considerations, charitable opportunities, Medicare-related income thresholds, and any planned Roth conversions or business income events.

In Florida, retirees often appreciate the lack of state income tax, but federal taxes still matter. Capital gains still matter. IRMAA still matters. RMD planning still matters.Florida does not make tax planning disappear. It just removes one layer.That is helpful, but not enough.

4. Revisit Withdrawal Sequencing

Which accounts should fund spending first? Taxable accounts? IRA assets? Roth assets? Cash? Pension income? Social Security? Business distributions?There is no universal answer. The right sequence depends on the family.But the sequence should be intentional. Random withdrawals can create avoidable taxes and reduce future flexibility.

5. Stress-Test Real Life, Not Just the Portfolio

A useful stress test should include more than a market decline.

• What happens if inflation stays higher than expected?
• What if one spouse dies earlier than expected?
• What if long-term care costs appear?
• What if a business sale is delayed?
• What if a child needs help?
• What if returns are lower for five years?

Those are not pleasant questions. They are useful ones.Better to ask them in a conference room than during a crisis.

Wealth Management Perspective

The best investors I have worked with are not the ones who never feel nervous. They feel nervous. They just do not let every market headline become a portfolio decision.

There is a difference. A serious wealth plan gives a family a process. Not perfection. Not a promise. A process.It helps decide when to hold, when to trim, when to raise cash, when to pay taxes, when to gift, when to wait, and when to ignore the noise. That last one is underrated.

“Sell in May” may be a decent reminder to look under the hood. Fine. Use it that way.

But do not let a market slogan make decisions for a multi-million-dollar family balance sheet. That is too much responsibility for a rhyme.

Should retirees sell investments in May?

Usually, not just because it is May.  Retirees should review income needs, liquidity, taxes, risk level, and portfolio allocation. If the portfolio is properly structured, a seasonal headline may not require much action at all. If the review reveals cash shortfalls or too much concentration, then adjustments may make sense.

Is “Sell in May and go away” a reliable investment strategy?

It is a familiar saying, not a complete investment discipline. Even if seasonal patterns show up in certain historical periods, implementing them consistently is difficult. Investors can miss rebounds, trigger taxes, and create new problems while trying to avoid temporary volatility.

What should affluent investors review before summer?

Start with cash needs, concentrated positions, unrealized gains, portfolio drift, tax exposure, charitable plans, upcoming capital calls, and retirement withdrawals. Do not start with CNBC.

Start with your own balance sheet.

Frequently Asked Questions

1.How much cash should retirees keep available?

It depends on spending, income sources, pensions, Social Security, portfolio risk, and personal comfort. Many retirees benefit from holding enough short-term liquidity to avoid selling long-term investments during a rough market. The right amount is personal. Too little cash creates stress. Too much cash can drag down long-term purchasing power.There is a balance.

2.Is rebalancing the same as market timing?

No. Market timing is trying to predict what happens next. Rebalancing is bringing the portfolio back to its intended risk level. One is a forecast. The other is maintenance.

3.Can selling investments create tax problems?

Yes.  Selling appreciated assets can trigger capital gains and may affect other areas of the plan, including estimated taxes, Medicare premiums, charitable giving, and future withdrawal strategy. That does not mean selling is wrong. It means the tax impact should be reviewed before placing trades.

4.Why does liquidity planning matter for wealthy families?

Because wealthy families still have cash flow problems if the timing is poor. A family may have plenty of net worth but limited available cash. Real estate, private investments, business interests, concentrated stock, and retirement accounts are not all equally liquid or equally tax-efficient. Liquidity planning helps turn wealth into usable flexibility.

Want a Clearer Retirement Roadmap Before Making Portfolio Decisions?

Before reacting to seasonal market headlines, it helps to step back and look at the full retirement picture.

That is why I created Your GPS to Holistic Retirement Planning — a free, self-paced course designed to help you understand how income, investments, taxes, Social Security, healthcare costs, and legacy planning all work together.The course is practical, straightforward, and built for people who want more clarity before making major financial decisions.No hype. No confusing jargon. Just a clear roadmap for turning retirement savings into a more coordinated plan.

Retire once. Stay retire

Start Lesson 1 Now