Deficits. The word alone can stir up a mix of worry and frustration, especially when we’re talking about trillions of dollars in national debt. As of September 30, 2024, the total U.S. federal debt hit a whopping $35.465 trillion—a staggering number that raises serious concerns about how future generations will handle this financial burden. But here’s the twist: while deficits are a long-term problem, they often fuel short-term stock market surges.

Yes, you read that right. Deficits, despite their grim long-term consequences, tend to be bullish for the stock market. In this post, we’ll break down why this happens, how history has shown this pattern time and time again, and why investors need to keep an eye on deficit trends. So, buckle up—this isn’t your typical doom-and-gloom debt discussion.

Why Are Deficits Bullish for the Stock Market?

First, let’s dive into the “why.” How can something as financially worrying as a deficit—basically spending more than what the government collects in taxes—be good for stocks? The answer boils down to one word: stimulus.

When the government runs a deficit, it typically pumps more money into the economy. This happens in the form of spending on infrastructure, social programs, and even defense. All that extra spending puts cash into the hands of businesses and consumers, which can lead to more corporate earnings, increased demand for products, and ultimately, higher stock prices.

In essence, the market gets a short-term sugar high from government spending. While the long-term consequences of rising debt are worrisome, stock investors—who often have a more immediate focus—see government deficits as a positive, at least in the short run.

Historical Patterns: Deficits and Bull Markets

This isn’t just theory—there are several key historical examples that show how deficit spending can boost the stock market. Let’s walk through some notable episodes where government efforts to reduce deficits or pay down debt led to bearish stock markets, and where running larger deficits provided a bullish backdrop for investors.

Episode 1: The Great Depression and Fiscal Conservatism (1929-1930)

In the late 1920s, right after the infamous stock market crash of 1929, the U.S. government under President Hoover tried to be fiscally responsible. They aimed to balance the budget, believing that tightening the belt was the best way to handle the economic downturn.

Unfortunately, this conservative approach—surpluses in both 1929 and 1930—proved disastrous for the economy and the stock market. Instead of stimulating growth, it worsened the economic collapse. The lack of government spending and stimulus led to even deeper financial pain, and stocks took a nosedive. This was the period when the thinking of economist John Maynard Keynes, who argued that deficits in times of crisis could help stimulate the economy, gained ground.

Episode 2: Post-WWII Debt Reduction (1946-1949)

Following World War II, the U.S. had an enormous debt burden after financing the war effort. In 1946, the federal debt peaked at 118.3% of GDP, but instead of letting the debt continue to climb, Congress made a point of paying it down. By 1948, the debt had fallen to 92.6% of GDP.

This reduction in debt, however, had consequences for the stock market. As the government cut back on spending to pay down the war debt, the bullish momentum from post-war recovery stalled. It wasn’t until Congress loosened the purse strings in 1949 that the stock market saw a return to growth.

Episode 3: The Eisenhower Era and 1957’s Market Pain

Fast forward to the 1950s, and we find another example of deficit reduction leading to market trouble. During President Eisenhower’s administration, there were efforts to reduce the national debt, which by the end of 1957 stood at 57.9% of GDP—a significant drop from previous years.

The stock market, however, didn’t react kindly to these fiscal efforts. The reduction in government spending led to a bear market in 1957, which saw stock prices drop by nearly 20%. It was a tough time for investors, many of whom saw the government’s austerity measures as harmful to economic growth.

Episode 4: The 2000 Surplus Scare and the Dot-Com Bubble

In the year 2000, the U.S. government came closer than ever to running a surplus. While that might sound like good fiscal policy, it didn’t bode well for the stock market. The lack of deficit spending removed some of the stimulus that had helped fuel the late 1990s’ booming economy. This contributed to the bursting of the dot-com bubble, and stock prices plummeted as the party came to an end.

Since then, both Congress and subsequent presidents have been content to run deficits—and the stock market has enjoyed the ride.

Current Trends: 2024’s Massive Debt and Stock Market Outlook

Now, let’s look at today’s situation. In fiscal year 2024, the U.S. added $2.297 trillion to its debt, bringing the total federal debt to $35.465 trillion. While that number is eye-popping and causes concern about the nation’s long-term fiscal health, history tells us that this level of deficit spending could continue to support a bullish stock market.

Additionally, it’s worth noting that deficits are not just bullish for stocks—they can also drive up gold prices. Gold tends to rise when deficits grow, as investors see it as a hedge against potential inflation or currency devaluation that might arise from government overspending. In fact, whenever the federal deficit as a percentage of GDP has risen, gold prices have generally followed suit.

What’s Next for Investors?

So, what does this all mean for investors today? While it’s important to acknowledge the long-term risks of high deficits, especially in terms of rising interest rates or inflation, the immediate outlook for stock market performance seems promising, if history is any guide.

Investors should keep an eye on how the U.S. government manages the deficit in the years to come, especially with a major election on the horizon. If the next administration continues the trend of running significant deficits, that could provide further tailwinds for the stock market and gold prices. On the other hand, any serious efforts to reduce the debt may bring about a more bearish market, as we’ve seen in previous episodes.

Final Thoughts

Debt may seem like an inevitable burden, but as we’ve seen, deficits have historically had a surprising upside for stock market investors. The injection of government spending that comes with deficit spending creates economic stimulus, and this can boost corporate earnings, stock prices, and even gold values.

While we shouldn’t ignore the long-term consequences of rising debt, understanding how deficits impact the stock market in the short term can help investors make more informed decisions. As 2024 comes to a close, and with an election just around the corner, it’s worth keeping a close eye on fiscal policy and its potential to shape market performance in the months and years ahead.

At AWM, our Fiduciary Duty Principles™ embody our commitment to transparency and integrity, ensuring you receive advice that aligns with your goals, not ours. This commitment sets us apart in a field where true fiduciaries are rare.

Knowledge is Power! Understanding the intricacies of the economy, markets, and broader financial policies is crucial—not just for staying informed but for taking control of your financial future. Knowledge equips you with the tools necessary to make strategic decisions, optimize your financial outcomes, and achieve financial freedom aligned with your life goals.

How Can We Help You? At AWM, we deliver proactive, comprehensive, and compassionate advice to individuals, organizations, and families. Our personalized solutions are tailored to meet each client’s unique needs, providing security and peace of mind.

Investment Management Explore our customized, globally diversified, tax-efficient investment portfolios designed to align with your financial plan and endure over time. Our Intelligent Allocation® technology dynamically adjusts to meet clients’ evolving needs in a fluctuating market environment.

Proactive Tax Planning and Management Explore innovative tax strategies designed to help you defer, reduce, and better manage your tax liabilities, with a focus on retirement and distribution phase planning.

Integrated Goals-Based Planning Incorporate all aspects of your life into a unified financial plan to navigate the optimal path to achieving your goals through any life event or transition.

Healthcare and Long-Term Care Planning Prepare for the future with comprehensive healthcare and long-term care planning that ensures you and your loved ones are well taken care of.

Social Security Optimization Maximize your Social Security benefits with our expert optimization strategies.

Estate & Legacy Planning Secure your legacy and ensure your estate is managed according to your wishes with our comprehensive services. We maintain strategic relationships with attorneys across 49 states.

First Step: Schedule Your Free Second Opinion Service Call Contact AWM today to schedule a confidential consultation and get matched with an advisor who can help you achieve your financial dreams.

Need Further Help? If you have any questions or need further assistance, please reach out to us at Service@awmfl.com.

 Thank you for your continued trust and engagement.

Tony Gomes, Author, MBA

CEO and Founder

Advanced Wealth Management

Content Disclosure: The information provided here is general and educational and not a substitute for professional advice. It has been prepared solely for informational and educational purposes and does not constitute an offer or recommendation to buy or sell any particular security or to adopt any specific investment strategy. While we believe the information shared is accurate and reliable, we do not guarantee its completeness or precision. The insights may include forecasts, opinions, and discussions about economic conditions, market scenarios, or investment strategies, which are subject to change.